Some remarks concerning the files collected:
The "classical" seki. gnugo plays correctly, but the score is wrong.
Here i wanted to see, if gnugo plays the stupid move C 1. Well it doesnt.
But maybe it is good to keep the file, just to make sure that future
"improvements" dont spoil it.
Thats what it is. gnugo makes mistakes and loses everything. But i get
the impression that the reading depth is just a little bit too short.
a seki. unless i counted it wrongly, assuming an equal number of
so there is a difference of 7 points, depending on which rules you take.
A double ko seki. with the present program and playing japanese rules
the eternal loop can only be avoided, if both players have enough
intelligence to see that it is impossible to win. i said already
before that i think that the program is wrong. that is after two
passes, i thought the game is finished, but do_pass allows gnugo
to play another move, so the loop continues. if we change do_pass,
it would be good enough to have one intelligent player to avoid
the loop. Since we know nothing about the intelligence of our
opponent, the intelligent player would have to be gnugo.
So if we stick to japanese rules, this needs a detailed analysis
In principle the japanese rules define in their precedents
that this position is seki, should gnugo know the precedents ?
chinese rules avoid the loop and give the interesting result, that
whoever insists on playing, loses everything. maybe not everybody
knows that already by heart, so it goes like this:
finally there will be no playable point left on the board.
lets assume that b has played the last possible move.
now w would like to take ko 2, but that is forbidden, because it
reproduces a position, which has already existed before.
If there is another ko somewhere else on the board, then this
double ko would be an example of what Ing calls a disturbing ko.
Another double ko seki. twoko_seki1 has two groups with an eye each,
this one has one liberty common to both groups.
A quadruple ko. I have never heard about that, but i guess the
japanese will have to cancel the game. with chinese rules one
can play it of course, but it is rather tricky.
The double ko variation of the onadare joseki.
Here i have added a ko in the lower right corner. This is completely
different from twoko_seki1.sgf plus another ko. here the black group
in the double ko is alive. however white has an unlimited supply
of ko threats, so it will win any other ko. If i understand this
correctly, the japanese do not consider this to be a triple ko
I thought that Ing should call the double ko a "fighting ko",
but apparently he doesnt. So the Ing rules would have to treat
the two cases twoko_seki1.sgf plus another ko and the present one
gnugo does not know how to handle this.
gnugo handles this correctly. when i said maybe for the wrong reasons
Gunnar said, what do i mean. well first one should look, if it does
all possible variations correctly. But what i really was afraid of, was
maybe it treats it the same way it handles seki. only for seki it is
wrong and here it is right. anyway, whenever the seki has been fixed,
one should look, if this is still ok.
Another one. This one is also handled correctly.
The combination of a bent4 with a seki, which gives an unremovable
ko threat. The japanese rules kill the bent4 anyway. gnugo has
I guess the japanese rules say that both groups are dead ???
Apart from that gnugo handles it correctly.
The "classical" triple ko. i guess, if we play japanese rules,
gnugo should realise that the game should be cancelled.
Playing chinese rules one can usually neutralise two ko's
and then play the one which is remaining as before.
This is a fake. white can never win this.
Similar to threeko2.sgf, with a slight difference. If it is
white's turn it can play B 5 and then it becomes a double ko
If it is black's turn, the japanese will cancel the game and
for the chinese white can never win.
A chosei( long life / eternal life ).
Apart from the fact that the game should be cancelled,
gnugo makes a lot of mistakes and loses everything.
It seems everybody who writes about that, shows the same diagram.
Maybe this is the only one ?
If people think that this is interesting, I would have to do
A junkan-ko (round robin ko). Everything I wrote about chosei
is valid here as well. i thought a little about these positions,
but i dont want to bore everybody, unless somebody really wants
projects / sgk-go / blob